21 Unusual Things to Do in New York City: Discover Hidden Gems

New York City is a vibrant metropolis brimming with iconic landmarks like the Statue of Liberty and Times Square. While these sites are impressive, the real magic lies in uncovering the city’s hidden gems. Beyond the well-trodden tourist paths, NYC offers a treasure trove of unusual experiences that promise to captivate and surprise you.

Imagine wandering through secret gardens or sipping cocktails in a renovated speakeasy. These are just a few of the unique activities waiting for you in the city’s less-explored corners. Whether you’re a local or a traveler, venturing off the beaten path reveals a side of New York that’s both intriguing and unforgettable.

From underground catacombs to the ultimate street fair, there’s no shortage of distinctive adventures in the Big Apple. So, if you’re ready to see New York City like never before, jump into this list of 21 unusual things to do and discover the city’s best-kept secrets.

Key Takeaways

• New York City offers a variety of hidden gems and unusual experiences beyond iconic landmarks, providing a fresh perspective for both locals and visitors.
• Embark on unique adventures by exploring secretive museums, indulging in outdoor activities, and delving into the city’s vibrant cultural scene.
• Standout experiences include visiting hidden speakeasies and unconventional dining spots, which transform meals into unforgettable events.
• NYC’s parks and neighborhoods offer distinctive activities and insights, from haunted history tours to serene green spaces like Little Island and Greenwood Cemetery.
• Discover unparalleled shopping experiences in the city, featuring unique markets and niche boutiques that highlight New York’s eclectic culture and innovative fashion scene.

Explore Hidden Museums

Step away from the usual tourist paths and jump into New York City’s hidden museums. These secretive venues offer a captivating mix of history, culture, and whimsy that fascinate explorers of all backgrounds.

Discover the Tenement Museum

Explore the Tenement Museum on the Lower East Side, where you can journey through time to experience the lives of New York’s immigrant families. Situated in two historical buildings, this museum showcases the stories of more than 15,000 people from over 20 countries. Engage with interactive tours that include actors and guides, allowing you to immerse yourself in the stories of yesteryear. Make sure to secure your tickets in advance—they’re $30 per person—and head to 103 Orchard Street for your tour.

Visit the New York Transit Museum

Venture to Brooklyn’s New York Transit Museum, tucked away in a historic 1936 subway station. This museum is a haven for history enthusiasts looking to explore a century’s worth of New York’s public transportation evolution. Marvel at vintage subway cars and buses, and investigate into exhibits detailing fare collection methods and subway construction. A visit on Thursday through Sunday between 10 am and 4 pm promises a memorable historical dive, with $5 admission for those with disabilities.

Immerse in the Mmuseumm Experience

For a one-of-a-kind experience, check out Mmuseumm—New York’s micro-museum dedicated to the overlooked, dismissed, or forgotten. Housed in a former elevator shaft in lower Manhattan, this museum is an ode to the richness of ordinary objects. It’s an open invitation to explore the peculiarities and curiosities that define human existence. Dive deep into unique exhibits and observe the world from a different perspective—all within the space of a few square feet.

Unique Outdoor Adventures

New York City offers a diverse range of outdoor activities beyond the typical tourist attractions. Jump into unique experiences and set out on adventures that provide an unparalleled view of NYC’s dynamic world.

Witness the View from Roosevelt Island Tramway

Experience the thrill of flying above the East River on the Roosevelt Island Tramway. This aerial journey gives you stunning views of the Manhattan skyline. It’s a must-try ride that combines affordability with excitement. Once you reach Roosevelt Island, begin on a self-guided exploration of iconic sites like Four Freedoms Park and the enigmatic ruins of the Smallpox Hospital.

Quick tip: the tram accepts standard metro cards, but remember you’ll need to disembark and pay again to catch a return trip. Operating from 6 AM to late hours, the tramway is a convenient option for both early risers and night explorers.

Stroll Through the Elevated High Line Park

Discover the High Line, an ingenious transformation of a former freight railway into a lush, elevated park. Walking along this elevated pathway, you’re treated to breathtaking views of the city’s skyline, surrounded by vibrant greenery and intriguing art installations. Feel the pulse of the city below as you wander through its unique sections offering intimate seating and open lawns. Free tours acquaint you with the park’s history and design, making your visit as enlightening as it is enjoyable. It’s a serene escape nestled amidst the city’s hustle, allowing you to relax without leaving Manhattan.

Explore Governor’s Island

Uncover the charm of Governor’s Island, a verdant sanctuary just a short ferry ride from the city. This car-free haven offers sprawling lawns and historical landmarks. You can rent bikes or pedal carts to explore the island or simply stroll along the pathways. The island hosts numerous seasonal activities, from art installations to educational exhibitions, making each visit unique. Remember to bring a picnic or explore the island’s food vendors for a delightful outdoor dining experience. Governor’s Island stands out as a refreshing retreat where you can reconnect with nature against the backdrop of the city’s iconic skyline.

Unusual Cultural Experiences

New York City offers a myriad of cultural experiences that extend beyond the customary tourist attractions, offering you a chance to investigate into the city’s eclectic artistic scene.

Attend a Burlesque Show at Company XIV

Immerse yourself in the world of Company XIV, a Brooklyn-based troupe acclaimed for its breathtaking blend of burlesque, cabaret, and ballet. As you step into this art house, you’ll find yourself amidst an extravagant universe where graceful aerialists defy gravity and performers donned in vibrant costumes dance through the aisles. This is an evening of playful fun and mesmerizing entertainment noted by the New York Times, promising an unforgettable and unique experience.

Experience Amateur Night at the Apollo

Visit the legendary Apollo Theater in Harlem for an authentic taste of New York’s musical heritage. Known as a launching pad for iconic artists like Aretha Franklin and James Brown, this venue hosts its renowned Amateur Night where hopefuls shine or falter under your cheers or jeers. It’s touted as one of the most entertaining nights in NYC, combining rich cultural history with a thrilling, interactive experience.

Revel in Shakespeare In The Park

Enjoy the magic of theater under the sky with the Public Theater’s Shakespeare in the Park in Central Park. This tradition offers free performances of Shakespeare’s masterpieces, reimagined with modern themes. Here, you’ll witness world-class productions directed by some of the most skilled artists, creating an accessible and enchanting cultural experience. Pack a picnic, grab your place in line, and soak in the artful storytelling amidst the natural beauty of the park.

Offbeat Dining and Drinking Spots

New York City offers extraordinary dining experiences beyond the typical restaurant scene. Discover hidden gems that transform meals into unforgettable adventures.

Dine Inside an Old Bank Vault at Trinity Place

Immerse yourself in history by dining at Trinity Place, located in the Financial District. This restaurant is set inside a restored 19th-century bank vault, complete with its original 35-ton steel doors and vaulted ceilings. Commissioned by Andrew Carnegie, this former world’s largest bank vault offers a unique ambiance where modern American cuisine intertwines with Old World splendor.

Sip Cocktails in a Hidden Speakeasy

Experience the thrill of secrecy by visiting hidden speakeasies that capture the allure of the Prohibition era. The Campbell Apartment, tucked away in Grand Central Terminal, transports you to a 1920s setting with its elegant decor and sophisticated atmosphere. If you’re in Midtown, head to the Burger Joint within the Le Parker Meridien hotel for a speakeasy-style surprise where high-quality burgers meet a casual, clandestine vibe.

Try Unique Street Food at Smorgasburg

Explore the vibrant culinary scene at Smorgasburg, a foodie haven that’s become a staple in NYC. This open-air market features a diverse array of street food vendors, offering everything from innovative fusion dishes to classic favorites. Whether you crave inventive snacks or international delicacies, Smorgasburg provides a feast for the senses and a perfect opportunity to taste the city’s hidden flavors amidst a lively crowd.

Intriguing Art and History

Explore some of New York City’s most captivating and unique art and history attractions. These destinations offer a distinct look into the culture and past of the city, perfect for curious and passionate travelers.

Uncover Secrets in the Basilica Catacombs

Discover the hidden catacombs beneath St. Patrick’s Basilica, a historical treasure not many visitors know about. Built in 1809, the basilica isn’t just a place of worship—it’s home to underground corridors and tombs where notable New Yorkers rest, such as the legendary Delmonico, credited with inventing the modern restaurant. Regular tours by Take a Walk grant exclusive access to these mysterious corridors under the city streets, offering a rare glimpse of New York’s secretive historic past.

Admire Street Art in Bushwick

Venture into Bushwick, Brooklyn, to immerse yourself in a vibrant, open-air gallery of street art. Known for its dynamic murals, this neighborhood showcases work from both local talents and international artists on its building facades. Take a leisurely stroll along Troutman Street and Jefferson Street to witness stunning, ever-changing pieces. Opt for a guided tour to learn about the artists and the stories etched into the walls, making it a must-see urban art experience.

Tour the Morgan Library and Museum

Visit Midtown Manhattan’s Morgan Library and Museum for an elegant jump into the world of rare books, manuscripts, and artwork. Originally the private library of J.P. Morgan, it now houses an extensive collection open to public exploration. Marvel at the exquisite architecture and view prestigious collections, including music manuscripts and early children’s books. Check out the various exhibitions on famous artists that take place throughout the year. If budget’s a concern, plan a visit on Friday evenings from 5 pm to 7 pm, when the museum offers free entry, although you’ll need a reservation.

With these destinations on your list, you’ll uncover layers of history and creativity woven into the fabric of New York City, enriching your travel experience beyond the usual itinerary.

Eccentric Activities

Step off the beaten path in NYC and discover activities that spark curiosity and adventure.

Partake in a Scavenger Hunt Across NYC

Join a scavenger hunt to explore New York’s landmarks in a dynamic way. With prices ranging from $7 to $45, these hunts take you through iconic spots like Central Park and Times Square while giving your exploration a competitive twist. You and your friends can solve clues and complete tasks, all while learning about the city’s intriguing history. It’s an engaging way to see the sights and uncover hidden stories.

Experience Indoor Skydiving at iFLY Westchester

Try indoor skydiving at iFLY Westchester for a high-flying thrill without jumping from a plane. At around $105, you get two one-minute flights, along with all necessary equipment. Feel the rush of wind and experience the sensation of free-fall in a safe, controlled environment. This unique adventure is available year-round, and no weather concerns to hold you back.

Join a Secret NYC Pub Crawl

Begin on a secretive pub crawl to explore the mysterious history of NYC. These excursions investigate into Prohibition-era tales and hidden locales that weave a narrative of secrecy and discovery. Knowledgeable guides lead you through obscure venues, offering insights into the city’s legendary days. Each stop unveils a piece of NYC’s storied past, making for an unforgettable evening of exploration.

Unique Ways to Enjoy NYC Parks

New York City isn’t just towering skyscrapers and bustling streets. It offers unique green spaces where tranquility and adventure coexist. Here are some standout ways to enjoy the city’s parks, blending nature with the vibrant urban backdrop.

Wander Through Little Island Park

Little Island, perched on the Hudson River, is an oasis of creativity and calm. Built on 132 tulip-shaped concrete pilings at Pier 55, this 2.5-acre park invites you to meander through imaginative gardens and winding paths. As you stroll, panoramic views of the Hudson and the distant city skyline unfold, providing a picturesque escape from the city’s hustle. Events often grace the large amphitheater near the river, enhancing the park’s artistic vibe. Early mornings or sunset visits best capture its serene charm, making it a favored spot for photos and peaceful reflection.

Find Serenity in Greenwood Cemetery

Venture into Greenwood Cemetery, a non-traditional park combining history and greenery. As one of the oldest cemeteries in the U.S., it offers a unique blend of historical narratives and architectural beauty nestled within peaceful landscapes. Join a guided tour to uncover stories of famous figures or explore solo and marvel at impressive mausoleums and monuments shrouded by ancient trees. For an atmospheric twist, nighttime tours introduce an eerie, yet enchanting perspective. It’s a serene spot where history whispers through the gentle rustling of leaves.

Explore the High Line

Elevated above Manhattan’s bustle, the High Line transforms an old freight railway into a public haven. This linear park showcases native flowers, art installations, and commanding views of the cityscape. Enjoy a leisurely walk among wild grasses and sculptures, or relax on a lounge chair with skyline vistas. It’s a popular destination for both locals and visitors seeking a unique vantage point of New York’s urban world. If possible, visit in the early hours or during weekdays for a quieter experience as you soak in artistic and floral delights.

Quirky Neighborhood Tours

Exploring New York City’s neighborhoods offers a window into its rich world of history and culture. Away from the bustling tourist spots, investigate into these unique tours that provide depth and character to your NYC experience.

Roosevelt Island’s Haunted History Walk

Roosevelt Island is not just about breathtaking views. Its haunting past adds layers of intrigue. Once home to smallpox hospitals and asylums, the island boasts eerie landmarks like the Smallpox Hospital Ruins. Guided walks reveal stories and secrets that won’t just make you shiver, but also enrich your understanding of New York’s past. Visit during twilight hours for an atmosphere that enhances the mysterious charm.

Discover the Charm of Prospect Park in Brooklyn

While Central Park gets most of the limelight, Prospect Park in Brooklyn is a verdant oasis worthy of a stroll. Created by the minds behind Central Park, this sprawling world is replete with wooded trails, a peaceful lake, and expansive meadows. Opt for a nature tour to learn about the park’s sustainability practices and seasonal beauty, from vibrant autumn foliage to spring’s floral displays. Don’t miss the LeFrak Center, a hub of recreational activities.

Walk Through Haunted Streets of Greenwich Village

Greenwich Village, with its bohemian flair, harbors many ghostly tales. This historic neighborhood is best explored on a haunted walking tour, which navigates through cobblestone streets lined with 19th-century brownstones. Discover ethereal tales at the New York University campus and Washington Square Park. Guides often share spine-tingling stories of famous residents and restless spirits, turning this quaint area into a spectral area. Consider visiting during Halloween for an even spookier vibe.

These neighborhood tours peel back the layers of New York City, allowing you to explore its rich narratives and unseen corners, providing experiences as unforgettable as the city itself.

Unusual Shopping Experiences

Explore New York City’s one-of-a-kind shopping adventures, where you can uncover hidden treasures, investigate into niche markets, and experience the city’s intriguing culture.

Discover Treasures at the Brooklyn Flea Market

Immerse yourself in the vibrant scene of the Brooklyn Flea Market, located in DUMBO and Chelsea. Known for its finely curated selection, you’ll find a treasure trove of vintage clothing, vinyl records, antiques, and handcrafted goods. It’s a perfect spot to snag eclectic finds that tell unique stories, all while soaking in the local culture. Don’t miss the array of food vendors offering delectable local treats to fuel your shopping spree.

Visit NYC’s First Vegan Boutique

Step into a world of sustainable fashion at New York City’s pioneering vegan boutique. At this East Village gem, you’ll discover clothing and accessories crafted from innovative materials like apple and cactus leather. This shop champions cruelty-free practices, making it ideal for eco-conscious shoppers. Enjoy a guilt-free experience, knowing every item supports fair labor practices. As you browse, you might even meet one of their friendly feline greeters, making your visit truly memorable.

Explore Tannen’s Magic Shop

Jump into the enchanting world of illusions at Tannen’s Magic Shop, nestled in Midtown Manhattan since 1925. This storied establishment is the oldest magic shop in America and a must-visit for budding magicians and curious minds alike. Within its walls, you’ll find a captivating collection of magic tricks, props, and accessories suitable for all skill levels. Enhance your magical prowess through private lessons and lectures offered here, as you immerse yourself in a community passionate about the art of magic.

Conclusion

New York City is a treasure trove of hidden wonders waiting to be uncovered. By venturing beyond the well-trodden paths, you’ll discover a city rich with unique experiences and vibrant culture. From secret gardens and speakeasies to captivating art and history attractions, NYC offers endless opportunities for exploration and adventure. Whether you’re a local resident or a visitor, embracing these unusual activities will provide a fresh perspective on the city that never sleeps. So jump into the lesser-known side of New York and let its hidden gems surprise and delight you at every turn.

Frequently Asked Questions

What hidden activities does the article recommend in New York City?

The article recommends exploring secret gardens, renovated speakeasies, and underground catacombs for a unique New York City experience. These places offer a deeper insight into the city’s rich history and culture beyond its famous landmarks.

Can you name a unique museum in NYC mentioned in the article?

The article mentions the Tenement Museum on the Lower East Side, where you can experience the lives of immigrant families. This museum offers interactive tours that reveal rich stories of past residents.

What unusual outdoor attraction is featured?

The article highlights the Roosevelt Island Tramway, offering stunning views of the Manhattan skyline. This unique mode of transportation gives access to sites like Four Freedoms Park for more exploration.

What culinary experience is emphasized in NYC?

The article emphasizes dining at Trinity Place, a restaurant housed in a restored 19th-century bank vault, for a mix of modern American cuisine with historical ambiance, enhancing your dining experience in New York City.

What are some offbeat performance art recommendations?

Recommended is Company XIV, a troupe in Brooklyn known for combining burlesque, cabaret, and ballet. Their performances offer a captivating and unique evening of entertainment that stands out in the NYC arts scene.

What hidden shopping gems are suggested?

The Brooklyn Flea Market is highlighted for its diverse selection of vintage clothing and antiques. It’s a must-visit for those looking to explore unique and curated shopping experiences in New York City.

Which park offers a serene escape amidst the bustling city?

The High Line, a transformed freight railway turned into an elevated park, offers a peaceful escape with its beautiful greenery and art installations, providing a unique vantage point of New York City.

What are some unique NYC tours for history enthusiasts?

The article recommends Roosevelt Island’s Haunted History Walk and Greenwich Village haunted walking tours. These tours offer a different perspective on New York’s past with intriguing stories and historical insights.

How can visitors participate in outdoor adventures?

Joining a scavenger hunt across NYC, which involves exploring landmarks while solving clues, is suggested as a thrilling way to engage in outdoor activities while learning about the city.

Are there any unusual cultural events to explore?

Yes, Shakespeare in the Park offers free performances of Shakespeare’s works in Central Park, providing an enchanting cultural experience surrounded by nature, perfect for theater enthusiasts and casual visitors alike.